Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bill Rice, Jr.'s avatar

I think Ms. Sinatra makes this point in her interview with Steve - the point being that, perhaps, the main justification for college students getting vaccinated was so they wouldn't spread the virus to the elderly, and more vulnerable, people in their college towns.

This argument is non-sensical too. College students do not have "close contacts" with people ages 75 and older (the vast majority of Covid victims). The average age of a Covid victim is 79 to 84.

Plus, if a college student was symptomatic and had Covid, he or she probably wouldn't be going and visiting their grandmother in the nursing home when they were sick.

Furthermore, we quickly learned that the vaccines don't stop infection or transmission so even if the student and their grandmother (who they don't see when they are in college) were both vaccinated this wouldn't prevent infection.

Every "rationale" for student vaccination was false.

Expand full comment
Bill Rice, Jr.'s avatar

There were approximately 18 million college students (undergrad to graduate) enrolled in America's 4,000 to 6,000 colleges in 2020.

From this number, I'd like to see a believable or definitive statistic on how many of these students died "from Covid" between February 2020 and February 2021. This would be the students who attended classes before students began receiving vaccines.

If an in-depth study of medical records subtracted any "Covid deaths" from students who already had multiple and serious co-morbid conditions, my guess would be that only maybe 20 to 50 students would be classified as dying from Covid.

If this is true, the simple mortality probability of a college student "dying from Covid" might be approximately 1-in-1 million to 1-in-500,000.

I would argue that no college student should risk taking an unproven experimental vaccine given death risks this miniscule. I'd also bet this death number would be roughly the same as the number of college students who die in one year from the flu.

You could also tally up all 4,000 colleges and see what number or percentage reported "no Covid deaths" among their student body in that 12-month period. This percentage would probably be 90 percent or greater.

* Note: I have written about a comprehensive UK study where researchers concluded that only six (6) "healthy" U.K children (ages 0 to 18) died "from Covid" in the first year of the official pandemic. If memory serves, There was 29 deaths from Covid, but 23 of these deaths were among children who had very serious, "life-altering" medical conditions when they died.

My guess is that the numbers of college students aged 18 to 24 would be very similar to the percentage of UK children 0 to 18 who died, according to that study. The odds a healthy UK child would die from Covid were greater than 1-in-1-million.

Given these mortality numbers, no vaccine should have been administered to any person aged 1 to 24.

I also wonder why no college statistics professor couldn't have found such data and told administrators what I just wrote.

Expand full comment
54 more comments...

No posts