Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bill Rice, Jr.'s avatar

I should note that many Covid writers and experts say that the absence of any “excess” all-cause deaths before mid-March 2020 “proves” there was no “early spread.”

However, I flip this narrative and say these people should check their assumptions. The main one being that widespread Covid leads to wide-spread death. I argue that the evidence of early spread shows that this virus was/is NOT a significant killer for the vast majority of the global population.

I’ll throw in one more piece of evidence from a study that is NOT anecdotal that I think supports my hypothesis. The Navy and CDC did an antibody study of crew members who were on the USS Teddy Roosevelt aircraft carrier, which left port in San Diego on January 17, 2020. As most will remember, this ship experienced a major outbreak.

From extrapolations, the antibody study results revealed that 60 percent of the crew of 4,850 sailors had been infected. That’s almost 3,000 crew members.

What’s noteworthy to me is that only one of these crew members died “from Covid,” and he was 41, one of the oldest people on the ship. In other words, the IFR for people under the age of 41 was 0.0000 percent. I also think evidence from this study strongly suggests this virus came on board that ship on January 17, 2020 - which would be before the first “confirmed” case in America.

Expand full comment
Bill Rice, Jr.'s avatar

Re: Anecdotal personal evidence …

I guess I can cite myself here. As noted in my article, in January 2020 I got very “sick” from “something.” I was bedridden for at least six days and was sick enough to go to the doctor which I rarely do. I got a flu test, which was “negative.”

An administrator friend who works at this medical clinic that serves 11 southeast Alabama counties later told me that my case was not atypical. The clinic was over-run by sick people in this time period and almost everyone was testing “negative” for the flu. The administrator told me, “We thought there must be something wrong with the flu tests.”

My symptoms were also not exactly like other cases of “flu” I had experienced in my life. For example, the cough was far more painful and intense. I’ve never experienced the “shortness of breath” I experienced in that week. Nor did I have the volume of phlegm I usually have with a bad cold or flu. I had terrible fatigue and my cough lingered for probably months. I also experienced an altered sense of taste, although I acknowledge this is common for many bugs.

Perhaps most convincing to me is that I never had Covid-like symptoms or tested positive with a PCR test after this January 2020 sickness. This suggests to me that I developed natural immunity to Covid.

Full disclosure, I should mention that I did later get an antibody test - four months after I was sick … and this test was “negative” for Covid antibodies. But as I have documented in other articles, I’m not sure I trust the results of the “authorized” antibody tests. I also know that in many people detectable levels of Covid antibodies can fade in two or three months. So even though I tested negative for antibodies, I still think I probably had Covid.

Expand full comment
74 more comments...

No posts